Donor Stewardship: Community-Centric Segmentation and Practices
Your top donors don’t just write big cheques; they could be folding newsletters in your conference room every Tuesday or serving on your board for the third consecutive year.
In this episode of The Small Nonprofit Podcast, Caitlin and Maria are exploring what it means to steward supporters through a Community-Centric Fundraising lens. We're sharing ways we’ve shown gratitude to people who show up for your mission with time, talent, advocacy, and yes, dollars too. We challenge the traditional approach of stewarding people based solely on gift amounts and explore who really deserves your high-touch attention (spoiler: it's not just your $1,000+ donors).
CCF Stewardship: The Highlights
1. Volunteers Are Major Donors in Disguise
Your regular volunteers are often contributing the equivalent of $15,000-$60,000 in staff time, yet most organizations don't steward them like major donors. That volunteer who designed your website for free? That's a $15,000 gift that deserves the same recognition as a financial contribution of that size.
2. Monthly Donors Deserve VIP Treatment
Even a $5 monthly donor should be in your major giving category. These supporters show incredible commitment and loyalty, and research shows they're likely to increase their giving over time. Plus, they're your best candidates for additional campaign gifts and planned giving opportunities.
3. Your Staff Are Subsidizing Your Mission
Every nonprofit staff member is essentially making a $20,000-$30,000 gift by accepting below-market wages. During the current hiring and retention crisis, treating staff with the same stewardship approach you'd use for major donors isn't just nice. It's smart business.
4. Longevity Matters More Than Single-Year Giving
A donor who's given $100 for five consecutive years is more valuable than someone who gave $500 once. Length of relationship and consistency of support are stronger indicators of future giving potential than one-time gift amounts.
5. Meaningful Stewardship Is About Connection, Not Cost
The most impactful stewardship often costs very little. A quick, personal email sharing a story you just heard can be more meaningful than an expensive branded gift. Authenticity trumps fancy materials every time.
🎧 Listen to our episodes for actionable fundraising tips and insights on nonprofit leadership, nonprofit governance, productivity & tools, and donor engagement strategies that work. We're here to eliminate nonprofit burnout and boost your donations!
✏️ Liked this episode? Have an idea?
👉🏼 Check out our past episodes
Subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Spotify or YouTube
If you want to learn how Further Together helps nonprofits raise more, this link will explain.
CCF Stewardship: 3 Actionable Tips
1. Audit Your Segmentation Beyond Dollar Amounts
Take your current "major donor" list and expand it. Add volunteers who contribute significant time, monthly donors regardless of amount, multi-gift donors (3+ gifts per year), and long-term supporters. Create a new category that values relationship and investment over pure financial capacity.
2. Create Budget-Friendly One-to-Many Stewardship
Record thank-you videos at your programs or events and send them to your entire donor base. Pre-write 5-6 impact stories at the beginning of the year and schedule them to go out every other month with no ask attached. These approaches let you steward your broader community without burning out your team.
3. Make Board Member Stewardship Individual
Stop treating board members as one group. They're individual volunteers who deserve personalized recognition. Try what worked for Caitlin's organization: surprise board members with a small branded gift bag including a chocolate bar, mug, honey, and handwritten note with sweet puns during Volunteer Week.
Resources:
Connect with our host, Maria Rio
Connect with our cohost, Caitlin McBride
Support our show. We are fully self-funded!
